Jeanette Winterson in the
Guardian, October 16, 2001:
My friend Ruth Rendell was in conversation at the Cheltenham Literary
Festival last weekend. Her sell-out audience was conservative and
over-50. Someone asked a question about pure evil, citing the
terrorist attacks on America as an example. With great presence,
Rendell replied that we could not categorise such attacks as evil,
since they were carried out from the highest motives and in the name
of freedom. The audience hated this reply—there was a collective and
audible shudder. Yet who reading Bin Laden's speeches can doubt it?
There is no cynicism in the man—he has never heard of a spin
doctor.... We need not sympathise with him to recognise a gulf between
the pragmatic concerns of the west and the fervent beliefs of the
east. How to bridge east and west is the question—and bombs are not
the answer.
Arundhati Roy, again, in the
Guardian, again, October 23, 2001:
Enduring Freedom for some means Enduring Subjugation for others. The
International Coalition Against Terror is a largely [sic] cabal of the
richest countries in the world. Between them, they manufacture and
sell almost all of the world's weapons, they possess the largest
stockpile of weapons of mass destruction—chemical, biological and
nuclear. They have fought the most wars, account for most of the
genocide, subjection, ethnic cleansing and human rights violations in
modern history, and have sponsored, armed and financed untold numbers
of dictators and despots. Between them, they have worshipped, almost
deified, the cult of violence and war. For all its appalling sins, the
Taliban just isn't in the same league.
†