School board member Steve Phillips, co-author of the multicultural
initiative, called the change "long overdue," adding that it would
make school work more "relevant" to public school students, only
11.8 percent of whom are white. "We recognize that public education
has been failing African-American and Latino students," Phillips
said. "Part of the reason is that the curriculum is not engaging
them. Students get more interested in reading and language when they
see themselves in the curriculum."
Other board members said the proposal would correct certain biases found in traditional high school reading lists. Board member Dan Kelly told the San Francisco Examiner that Mark Twain's Huckleberry Finn was biased against African Americans, and that Chaucer's Canterbury Tales, while a great work, characterized people based on their class.